4 Bedroom Rentals

Click photo or house name for more information!


Total Price: $2241

Located far on the SW side of the island, this 4 BR / 2 BA home is very basic but has everything you need for a relaxing vacation. Mowed walking trails. Max 7 people. Pet Friendly. Sat-Sat Rental.


Total Price: $3213

Classic 4 BR / 2 BA BI cottage located on Mansion Beach Road. Walk to the beach or relax on the private back deck with pond views. Max 8 people. Sat-Sat Rental

Abbott 003

Total Price: $3510

Historic BI farmhouse and barn located near the North end. Each building has 2 bedrooms and 1 bath. Large yard with outdoor dining table and walking trails. Max 7 people. Pet friendly. Fri-Fri Rental


Total Price: $3591

Relax in this 4 BR / 1.5 BA home located near Dories’ Cove. Large yard with access to a small pond. Comfy living room and lovely back deck. Max 8 people. Pet Friendly. Sat-Sat Rental.

Saylor 002

Total Price: $3618

Beautiful 4 BR / 2.5 Bath home located within walking distance to Scotch Beach. Large open kitchen / dining / living room is perfect for families. Small, nice yard. Max 8 people. Pet Friendly. Sat-Sat Rental.


Total Price: $3672

Enjoy views of the North Light and BI Sound! This 4 BR / 2.5 Bath features 2 kitchen / living / dining areas and large second story deck for taking in the views! Max 8 people. Sun-Sun Rentals. 


Total Price: $3715.20

Spacious 4 BR / 2.5 BA home located near Mohegan Bluffs. Comfortable living spaces, wrap-around deck, and nice backyard for games. Max 8 people. Pet Friendly. Sat-Sat Rental.


Total Price: $3748

This 4 BR, 3 BA home has easy access to Crescent Beach (between Mansion and Scotch). Comfortable living space and large south-facing deck. Max 8 people. Pet Friendly. Sat-Sat Rental.


Total Price: $3862

Enjoy beautiful long-range ocean and island views from this old BI farmhouse perched on Beacon Hill. Built on 12 acres, this house offers plenty of privacy. Max 8 people. Pet Friendly. Mon-Mon Rental.


Total Price: $5103

Spacious 4 BA/ 3 BA near Fresh Pond offers plenty of room for a group of 10! Well-decorated with comfy places to relax. Large deck and mowed lawn for outdoor enjoyment. Max 10 people. Fri-Fri Rental.


Total Price: $5697

Well-appointed 4 BR/2 BA home on the quiet West Side. Lovely furnishings, chef’s kitchen, ocean views and large deck area. Air Conditioning!!Max 8 people.


Total Price: $6858

Beautiful 4 BR, 4.5 BA located off Spring Street with water views from most rooms. Three levels of living space and large yard. Lovingly maintained. Max 8 people. Fri-Fri or Mon-Mon Rental.


Total Price: $7360.20

Stunning new construction 4 BR, 4 BA home located high on hill with ocean and island views. Whole house A/C and beautiful amenities. Max 8 people. Mon-Mon Rental.